Home Blog Page 280

Who Should be the Starting Running Back?

70

Cliff is reporting that Terron Ward is getting the most reps, and that Agnew looks good.

My question: would you be comfortable with either of these guys being the starting RB?

Agnew fumbles too much. Ward runs upright, has short strides, and I don't believe has the durability (of a Quizz) to last more than a few games as a featured back. Ward should be a backup, or at the most a 3rd down back.

I've been waiting/hoping for Brown to beat them out, but according to Cliff it sounds like that isn't going to happen. Is Riley making another personnel error, or should we all shut our traps because "coach knows best"?

Day 6 Practice Report

106

From SilverStream:

I attended most of the Beavers' midday practice today/Saturday at Prothro Field (11 am to 1:15 pm).  I spent most of my time focusing on the O-line.

Freshman o-lineman Gavin Andrews participated in the first part of practice, until his head started hurting.  He sat down on a half wall near the sidelines, looking dazed and sick, leaning forward and holding his head in his hands.  Head Trainer Arika Iso came over and talked with him for about five minutes.  From the parts of the conversation I could overhear, it seems that Gavin banged his head hard in practice yesterday/Friday, but didn't tell the trainers.  He is now suffering from what may be a concussion, and was taken to the training room for further tests and observation (after a lecture from Arika Iso about the need to tell the trainers immediately about this sort of problem in the future).

A kinder, gentler Coach Cav was on display for at least the first half of practice today.  He was doing a lot of teaching during O-line drills, in a relatively calm voice.  Towards the end of practice, during 11-on-11 drills, the old Cav emerged and did some yelling.  But overall Cav seems to be trying to do less screaming and cursing, and trying to be more constructive with his criticisms.

I spent a lot of time watching Isaac Seumalo today.  Isaac is playing center with the first unit, and looks surprisingly comfortable in that position.   QBs were taking most or all snaps with their hands under center, and Isaac appeared to be doing a reliable job with the snaps.  After snapping the ball, Isaac was getting off the line quickly, and up into the pads of the d-line.  During 11-on-11 drills, Isaac held his own against Castro Masaniai, and the other interior d-linemen.  In fact, I only saw Isaac get beaten a few times all day (and it was a long practice).   Isaac also did a nice job in 11-on-11 drills releasing from his initial block and picking off linebackers on draw and screen plays.  If there was anything negative to say about Isaac, perhaps it was that, during blocking drills early in practice, Isaac did not look so sharp on shotgun snaps (but, in fairness, the shotgun snaps were being snapped back to an OSU assistant, and were not at all the point of the drill).  From what I saw today, I expect that Isaac will be OSU's starting center on September 1, and will do a good job.

The O-line first unit today included Mike Philipp at LT, Josh Andrews at LG, Isaac at center, Grant Enger at RG, and Colin Kelly at RT.  When I wasn't watching Isaac, I was watching Mike Philipp. I thought MP looked good — certainly better and healthier than last year.  Again, just from what I saw today, I expect MP to bounce back and have a good season at LT for the Beavs.  At the very least, MP will represent a major upgrade from last year's LT, Mike Remmers (although that's not saying much, of course….)

Garrett Weinrich played LT with the second unit during today's practice.  GW doesn't seem to get off the ball quite as fast as Isaac Seumalo, and got beaten a bit more often as a result, but still held his own most of the time against various D-linemen (including Dylan Wynn).  GW appears to have good size and strength already (and will presumably improve in these areas).  He also seemed already to know his assignments — I don't recall GW getting yelled at much today by Cav, or by other coaches.

Nolan Hansen is a freshman offensive lineman from Corvallis HS.   NH is listed at 6-6 and 250, but looked lighter than that.  If NH is going to play o-line for OSU, he will need to add 50 pounds and a lot of strength.  His main role today was as a blocking dummy.  At best, he'll be given a chance to redshirt this season and to hit the weights (and the training table) hard.  No help coming from NH in the near future.

Apart from the O-line, I only have a few other observations from today's practice:

Rashaad Reynolds looked good at CB all day.  I think his one-on-one pass coverage — and especially his press coverage — will be significantly better this season than last season.  Today he showed an ability to come up close to the line, then backpedal quickly, and  stay with Wheaton and Cooks on most pass routes, keeping tight coverage all the way down the field.  This was true even though RR had his right knee wrapped in an athletic bandage (suggesting that he wasn't 100%).   Perhaps I'm imagining this, but RR seems — at least to me — to be more confident, and mentally tougher, than he was a year ago.  If RR and Poyer stay healthy, OSU should be in good shape this season at CB.

Mannion seems to be throwing his short passes (10-15 yards) with slightly more velocity, and also more accuracy, than last year.   He seems to be making an effort to keep the ball down — letting fewer balls sail on him (which was sometimes a problem last year).   In the short passing game, Mannion also seems to be making decisions and getting rid of the ball a bit more quickly.  So far, so good.

Oh, and Richard Mullaney participated fully in practice today and looked good (so the hand injury he sustained yesterday probably was not too serious).

Riley Makes Changes to Seem “Proactive”

138

See Cliff's article, mentioning how Riley has once again made changes to practice this year.

Remember last year when Riley made changes, and fans were like, "Hey, he's adjusting to the modern game, yada yada"? How did that turn out?

The reality is that Riley is making changes just to look proactive. I wrote this comment on Cliff's blog:

Riley makes a change that doesn’t work every year just to look like he’s doing something pro-active. This will fail, too, because he doesn’t know what the hell he’s doing. Success starts with recruiting. Riley can’t recruit. He also can’t even put the best players on the field (#28, Pankey, R. Robinson, etc).

I think that sums it up. New year + same philosophy hidden behind "new changes" + same head coach = same capped results. I'll stop criticizing when he puts the 11 best players on the field, has an ideology change, understands the importance (and value) of recruiting talent vs "coaching up", etc. Slowing down practice to focus on detail a year after he thought speeding up practice because he believed reps were important doesn't scream "man with a refined football philosophy."

Now granted, I've been harping that his teams have no attention to detail, so that part is good, but the point is that Riley is all over the map, and it comes off as change for the sake of change, to rally his supporters by suggesting that with the "changes" this year it's going to be different, or to have tangible effort to show Bob D when they sit down at season's end. You're already seeing the media buy in: (paraphrasing) "Riley is changing around practice, and he looks invigorated!" These people have to sell content. Riley can't even put the best players on the field, and the media is too dumb to realize that and question it, yet I'm supposed to believe their reports? Give me a freaking break. This is the same coach pulling the same "I'm a nice guy who's adapting to modern football" illusion he's been pulling for the past three years–ever since the Pac got stronger and exposed him for what he's always been–a mediocre, aging coach.

Day Three Practice Notes

93

From various sources:

Derek Nielson stepped in for Colin Kelly. Nielson is a walk-on. Gavin Andrews has looked good, and I expect he'll start to see time at RT.  You can see here I had Andrews as my #2 prospect in the 2012 class.  Looks like I'm going to be spot-on with him (and Cowdin, hehe).

Isaac is ready to start. Philipp is back in shape. Beavs now have two 4-star talents on the line. They should be better for that alone, and Josh Andrews is no slouch. Enger and the RT need to step up their game. Enger will be fine, IMO, though he should be a tackle not a guard.

Trent Bray is having an impact already.

Punting situation is still a nightmare. Both guys (Kostol and McMullen) are shankapotomuses…I think McMullen wins the job because he can rugby kick better. Hopefully the kid they just signed, Garrett Owens, gets in the mix next year if not this…either of the current two guys will cost the Beavs games this year. Historically, Riley would rather have a 5th string LB than a scholarship punter…fine, but realize it's going to cost the team wins and possibly his job.

Riley wants Chris Brown to be the RB but wants him to earn it. I think Agnew is in his doghouse. Woods and Brown are the guys right now. I think Brown needs to start, and Woods should be the 3rd down back. Tyler Anderson needs to be the FB, too, but haven't heard much about him. He's a pass catching threat with good wheels.

Zimmerman is running with the first team (Didn't I/we just mention he should supplant Watkins?). Riley, you reading this?

First Day of Fall Camp

246

Dylan Wynn the first player on the field. No surprise there. Michael Philipp right behind him, a good sign.

Riley's father passes away the first day of fall camp–more Beaver bad luck.  RIP, Bud…

Silverstream, will you be attending practices this Fall?