220 COMMENTS

  1. This was so unexpected……..again I’d like to thank my parents and coaches, without thier guidance, I wouldn’t have made it to this point.

  2. People like to talk about a team “jelling”, but you can’t lose games like this if you want to make the NCAA’s.

    7 Beav turnovers in the first 8 minutes to 0 for Lamar (13 pts off of them).

    Lamar brings back some bad memories of tournament failures in the Ralph Miller era.

  3. Beavs down 10 with at least 22 turnovers.

    Kind of reminds me of that game during the CR era when they lost to Seattle U 99-48. You can’t believe what you’re seeing, but unfortunately it’s real.

    Mike Montgomery is ponderous.

  4. Turns out losing your first, second, and third string point guards is hard to overcome. Still though…Lamar? This loss felt very Craig Robinson-y. Hopefully the team wakes up and Stevie turns out to be a difference maker but this has the looks of a rebuilding year early on

  5. Other than the initial exhibition game against Western Oregon (and that didn’t count), this is probably the first WTF loss of the Tinkle era. We have the no STj excuse and given the suspect performance against UTSA, they need him badly. Let’s see where Tinkle goes from here. My fear is that GP-2 was a very unique college player and he’s not going to be replaced in one season.

    • “What’s a Lamar???”

      The guy who led off the gang bang on your mom.

      Cute play on a men’s gymnastics contraption in your username though. +1/4

          • I posted about someone’s mother getting gang-banged?

            I expected this psytrance noise to manifest down the line, giving people the chance to wonder what started it all but not caring enough to really find out. That you wang it out on the very first post in reply is not a first for me. But it does make life easier, and that’s a rarity.

            Thanks.

          • I’m not sure what a pummel course is. It sounds like something a jarhead would get excited about.

            For those on the admin side here, are IP addresses visible for all these comments? I have a feeling someone is blaming me for something I do not do… while probably doing so quite a bit himself… and it can easily be proven.

            It’s so typical that it has a stereotype.

  6. Is there a possibility that Malcom D returns for the winter quarter? They need a steadying influence in the backcourt. That was terrible last night.

  7. Well, reading the comments, guess I’m glad I was stuck at work til 10:30 and missed the game.

    If anyone is interested in tickets, no not for Lamar- although you can have those too, I’m swamped with work for the next month, happy to send tickets we have in the upper reaches of Gill.

    • All the stats you need to know:

      A/TO: 11/27
      FT by bigs not named Tres: 3-8
      FT by “other than” bigs: 1-1
      Shot differential for the winning team: 71/47

      • When you shoot 27% on limited shots from downtown, we could put together a team of you, me and our four grandmothers and beat that team with a soft zone.

  8. I haven’t read all the comments, but I think this loss may be a good wake up call for some young players that you need to come out ready to play.

    We need to work on handling press and trapping.

  9. The only bright spot for me in last nights game was Eubanks. Love how he is playing this year. Just needs to worry more about scoring then show-off dunks. Coach Tinkle commented in an article before the game that he was worried about to much playing time right away for the fresh off an injury little Tinkle. I think coach was right… little Tink looked tuckered out last night. All the other rookies had a hard time playing with their thumb in their mouths.

    • Jaquori was fine as well if we’re using Drew as a barometer. He only made one less FT than Drew, and they had about the same amount of TOs. And Stacy was better than he had been. But a line of 7/2/2/2 with a .667 A/TO is not good for a starting PG on this level. So that’s just a relative gain.

  10. At last night’s basketball game against Lamar, I mostly watched Tres Tinkle, to see whether he would play less selfishly after filling the stat lines the past two games and winning PAC-12 player of the week. Here’s what I saw.

    Tres spent much of his time of offense standing around the perimeter and calling for the ball. Tres only took 7 shots from the field last night (1 for 7), but many of those were forced. Tres had five turnovers, including a number of misguided attempts to dribble through traffic. Tres had only two assists, despite logging 36 minutes of playing time (most on the team). Tres got most of his points from the foul line, as he repeatedly forced up shots while covered, and ended up taking more than half of the team’s foul shots (Tres hit 7 out of 10 foul shots; the rest of the team hit 4 out of 9 foul shots).

    Perhaps more concerning, one could make a case that Tres is getting favored treatment from his dad. When other guys commit turnovers, they often get pulled quickly. In contrast, Tres led the team in turnovers last night, while also leading the team in minutes played. When other guys take bad shots, again they often get pulled quickly. When Tres takes bad shots, Wayne usually shrugs his shoulders.

    It wouldn’t be surprising if some of his teammates started to resent this sort of stuff. There were a few times last night where I thought I saw teammates choosing not to pass to Tres. Going forward, this may be something to watch out for — as an indicator of developing chemistry problems on this team. Hope I’m wrong about this….we’ll see.

    • Typically when you’re talking about one person, you don’t need to repeat his name at every opportunity. We have these things called pronouns. I get that you may be trying to prove a point by doing it, because your premise of reward for poor play is visible. But it’s really unnecessary. We’re a stupid country, but we’re not THAT stupid.

    • Interesting look at things. I did see coach go off on Stacy (I think) for a very bad pass that was a turn over. I have always been a little concerned over the father – son dynamics and how that will play out with the team. My bigger concern is this though… Coach has always been known for his defensive teams and not his offenses. I think in this league you need both, or at least a great defense and good offense. We’ve had really good defense since coach tink arrived, but I have always felt our offense was just not that great.

      • GP 2 made the defense much better. Eubanks is the only superior athlete at his position. The rest are average or below average. Little Tinkle(Dribble) is slow afoot and not a great leaper to play the 3 spot. He gets by because of good fundamentals, but his drives have an increased level of difficulty because he can’t blow by or elavate above the defenders.

    • It looked more like they don’t have a feel for each other. Can’t read the intentions of the other players. So many unforced errors.

      Stacy is out of sync the most. Sometimes trying too much, trying to make a low percentage pass.
      Dew – Too much time holding the ball. Shouldn’t be handling the ball as much as he is. Needs to pass the ball quickly and move. The upside is that he is long and should be able to defend on the perimeter.
      McLoughlin – Adjusting to a new level of competition. Looks a bit overwhelmed with the speed of the game. He’s quickly finding out that his moves from high school don’t work as well at this level.

      Don’t have much to say about the others since they weren’t expected to be impact players.

      Tres looked like he didn’t trust the new guys too much. The first few games, they’ve been turnover machines. Part of it is obviously because they haven’t played together for very long.

      The defensive end looks fine. Held Lamar to 28% shooting which should be expected.

      • He’s right, though. Tres didn’t add the other paint presence he usually adds. He could have exchanged all his TOs for trips to the line if he wouldn’t have been standing around the perimeter all game. Not trusting the other guys is one thing. Not putting yourself in a position to play your game is something completely different. And a coach allowing someone who didn’t come to play to stay on the floor is another still.

    • Tres didn’t want to do it last night either. And the problem with him is that his game relies on him eating space. If he goes and hides on the perimeter, he takes away his own game.

      • Agreed re Tres taking away his own game last night by hanging around the perimeter and asking teammates to pass him the ball.

        At the same time, as you said in another comment, there is a problem with “…a coach allowing someone who didn’t come to play to stay on the floor” — especially where that player is the coach’s son.

        After the game, asked about Tres’s poor performance, Wayne said: “”He just wasn’t at his best obviously.” http://www.oregonlive.com/beavers/index.ssf/2016/11/oregon_state_mens_basketball_s_10.html#incart_most-readbeavers

        OK. But the follow-up question to Coach Tinkle should have been: “Then why did you give Tres more playing time last night than anyone else?”

        • A homer press is less inclined to ask that question until they’ve had a chance to digest the stats. And I don’t see much in terms of press on hand who can translate what they see on the stat sheet quickly enough to ask during the post-game.

          It could have been that he just didn’t have a contingency, and he plays it conservatively. If he looks at the tape and justifies those stats with the same treatment next time out, would our press have the wherewithal to also see it and then ask?

          • I would think that doesn’t need to be a follow-up. I think silverstream is hinting that it might be a leading factor for his poor performance, not a symptom of it.

            It could be an innocuous lead-in for the subject at hand, which I think is rewarding poor play with a bias.

  11. Zona playing it on the down low on who will start Saturday. Dawkins and Solomon can go. I’d rather deal with Solomon, Dawkins is a better runner… which is a big part of their game.

  12. Sure Lamar got more points. Big deal.

    The Beavs; out rebounded them 51-38, led in assists 11-10, Blocked shots 10-2 and field goal percentage 49% to 28%.

    The Electoral College will meet and declare that the Beavs won the game! Chalk up a big win!!

  13. Wondering out loud: I see Gligorije Rakocevic has played 6, 2 and 6 minutes in the first 3 games. Is that in part because WT is playing the other bigs to see how they do (and fit in) or is it because GR isn’t very good?

    • Do you realize that with that link we can now see where you spend your time looking for news?

      Wasn’t there a site who could make it into 10 pictures with a different sentence from that article under each picture? They don’t even have to be pictures of Benjamin. They can just promise to list the Top 10 sentences from their article, and people would keep clicking.

  14. Sorry to change the topic from the hoops disaster, but I need a place to vent. This political stuff is getting out of hand.

    http://www.oregonlive.com/trending/2016/11/privilege_white_teens_wont_tol.html

    The media keeps encouraging people that demonstrating/protesting gives you some kind of voice that people will listen to. I did not vote for Trump and I don’t like him, but I feel like everyone is taking crazy pills. Is he racist? He is likely slightly prejudice, but realistically this guy is not an outright racist or mysoginist. People need to calm the fuck down.

    Such a vocal minority of folks that are overy sensitive to the slightest of perceived “threats”. From the article, this would have made me laugh if the response to it wasn’t such an incredible overreaction:

    “In June, a homeless man shouted about the KKK while threatening a black actress with the Oregon Shakespeare Festival.

    In response, Black Lives Matter signs are still visible on yards, Shakespeare festival members walked in the July Fourth parade wearing Black Lives Matter T-shirts and festival management issued a statement that it was not an isolated incident: “The sad truth is that people of color often feel unwelcome and unsafe in our beautiful town and region. It’s time to talk about it and to take action.”

    Why is “taking action” an appropriate response to some crazy homeless person shouting something racist? There are over 300 million people in this country and people are protesting (and getting media coverage for it) a crazy homeless guy that said something racist.

  15. Lots of random attacks lately Jack. Your ego is remarkable. Who are you too judge? I have never been to the TMZ website but using such a small window to make such a substantial judgement is narrow minded. Way off point as well.maybe it’s not creditable but the source was given.Que quippy remark.

    • I’ll wait for you to extol TMZ’s virtues in order to back up everything you just said about my narrow-mindedness. If you can prove its value as a creditable news source, I’ll listen. Hell, if you can prove that it’s better than anything else Time Warner owns, that would be news to me.

      You can also point out any of these random attacks. I don’t think I have any posts lately that aren’t a direct reply to topics and demeanors already in existence. Are you saying nobody should call anything out? Do you think calling something or someone out is an attack?

      With words.

      I see the whiny sensitivities of America still exist.

      Don’t make dumb off-topic posts (or in this case link to junk sites), and these stupidities will not ensue. Do so, and you know exactly what you’re going to get. Go ahead. I’m easy, and this is even easier to do. I don’t care either way.

  16. Since we’ve gone to the “wide ranging topics” mode, there is this which may actually be of value to some here:

    “A rare bile duct cancer that may be linked to time served in the Vietnam War is quietly killing some former soldiers. The disease can be caused by liver flukes, a parasite found in raw or undercooked fish that is common in parts of Asia. Some veterans are fighting for the Department of Veterans Affairs to recognize their disease as service-related so they can receive benefits, but most claims are denied.

    http://www.mercurynews.com/2016/11/15/vietnam-war-veterans-attacked-by-rare-cancer-linked-to-liver-flukes/

    • Sad that the country only pays lip service to veterans. Maybe they should have tried getting their issue linked to being not white or not straight where possible. Then the media and Obama administration would have been all over it.

      Gotta work within the system.

        • The priority should be veterans………period. Obama was hammered from both sides to fix the VA about 2 years ago, and didn’t.there is still a mile long back log that hasn’t shrunk since that time. But he did make sure trannys can piss in whatever bathroom they choose. So there’s that.

          • HR 466
            HR 1168
            HR 1171
            HR 1172
            HR 1293
            HR 1803
            HR 2352

            1293 really really pisses me off because it hasn’t been changed in 24 fucking years. For those keeping score, that was back when the GOP figured active duty pay was also as good a political football as pissing on vets and telling them it’s trickle down theory… and some of them (and you) buying it.

            But the GOP can eat shit and die the same deaths they made my friends and family die just because they treat vets they do. We won’t go into how they hate active duty personnel just as much unless they can hang a flag on their woodies.

          • Ok…….did the GOP make doctors and administrators falsify veterans records to show compliance to VA rules? Like the last time this came up 2 years ago? Your hero Obama sure fixed it didn’t he? Oh wait he was busy golfing to give a shit.
            Oh and the reason those bills didn’t pass is because of Finestein didn’t bring them to a vote and passed them back to the veteran affairs committee…….which I think she was on and I’m sure Wyden was on it also. Did you call Wydens office and bitch at him? But way to pass the buck to the GOP.

          • There is no fucking buck to pass because the god damned GOP will not pass it if it makes Obama look good.

            Obama’s not my hero. He could have rammed through real and lasting health care when he had the chance, but he chose to go with Romneycare instead. And it was evident he would do this as early as the summer of 2008. But you digress… yet again.

            The bills I listed were all killed by the GOP. And I haven’t updated that list in years. If any action (like sending them back to committee) occurred, it was because the GOP invoked cloture. Did you not follow any of the links giving you quotes by Sessions et al?

            Why am I asking? Of course you didn’t.

          • *Dems couldn’t invoke cloture

            I shouldn’t be too hard on the GOP as a whole. It was only their Senators who killed bipartisan House bills.

            And don’t make me defend Feinstein. I see what happened with EG&G.

        • I don’t know if you’re lumping me in there with “us straight white guys” but that would be incorrect. And we’re talking veterans here.

          • Maybe they should have tried getting their issue linked to being not white or not straight where possible.

            That’s you talking veterans… here. I see how in-depth you are, talking about the real issues… not paying lip service.

            Golly!

            I wonder how anyone would be confused about that?

          • *you did say “where possible”

            I missed that. But the next time I see one of these self-righteous chickenhawks who blames Obama for the GOP’s misdeeds working in a soup kitchen serving homeless vets, it will be the first time.

            Oh… wait… second time…
            http://www.cbsnews.com/news/charity-president-paul-ryan-did-nothing-at-soup-kitchen-photo-op/

            I never did understand how he got callouses when he was young and washing dishes. I washed dishes for three years, and that removed a lot of the callouses I got from my day job at the time.

          • You sort of have a point there.

            But as much as I’m at odds with Obama’s stated policies (not the hysterical imaginations of the GOP strawmen of Obama) he has just been hindered at every turn by a spiteful group of lizards with forked tongues. I can’t imagine what the weak of mind would say about the Dems if they did the same to any GOP prez. I know I would be screaming at a different party. But I get the feeling you would heartily be on the same side you are now, blindly screaming at one party just because.

          • No “blind screaming.” My point is that Obama’s priorities generally begin and end with racial and sexual minorities. Could probably add religious minorities to that list. Everyone else like a group largely of white dudes like Vietnam veterans, be damned. They don’t really matter to him, and looking at how Hillary basically ignored rural America, they didn’t matter to her either (except as a target for scorn, blame, and ridicule.)

            The good news is that with Trump as president, rest assured we will end up with plenty more lipservice. Maybe even twice as much! Oh boy!

          • My point is that Obama’s priorities generally begin and end with racial and sexual minorities. Could probably add religious minorities to that list.

            No… they don’t… unless you’re thinking that equality means something different than equality. But that would be blindly screaming what the propaganda tells you to scream day in and day out.

            I won’t defend HRC at all. Obama, at least, is worth defending as a man and a pol, no matter his policies. HRC is just Ronald Reagan making fun of a different group of people… except he probably had more baggage when he was elected.

            But I will say that she didn’t just ignore rural or homogenous groups. Her center-right policies have been implemented for over 35 years in this country, and people could see it because she didn’t pay lip service to those who she would have vote for her. She seriously thought everyone who had so little mental capacity that they believed a fucking word out of King Birther’s mouth deserved derision.

            And she’s not wrong in a holistic sense. But she was also stupid enough to think she could run for office and make fun of people without them noticing? After the Bernie Bro fiasco, I wasn’t going to give her any platform in my head. Trump just never earned one. In fact, he went from being someone who bilks workers and doesn’t pay his bills, instead going to court not to pay what he owes, to a seriously laughing matter. But I still didn’t say anything real about him before the election because he’s such a dumb, cheating, lying fucker that anything said by me would be lumped in with HRC-speak.

            But I’m free to do so now. The Comedian in Chief is in the house. Let the bilking of America begin.
            http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/18/us/politics/donald-trump-transition.html?_r=0

            You just can’t make this shit up.

          • I never said or pretended they were homogenous. I said Vietnam vets are largely white. Any quick search for the stats will tell you ~85+% of men serving in that war were Caucasian. All races’ contribution is important, but that doesn’t change the factual demographics. Vietnam vets are mostly white dudes.

            Stop throwing tangents and strawmen around, Jack.

          • You’re making the same mistake you have always made here. You’re making the same mistake HRC made with the Bernie Bros and blue collar workers. You’re breaking it down to one group and speaking for them as if a majority or minority is or will be affected by this or that.

            Equality is just equality. And all policies affect these subgroups the same regardless their personal demographic outside whatever subgroup we’re talking about. All vets are affected the same by this negligence of playing political football with them. Our infrastructure sucks in every corner of our country because one political philosophy has a utopian vision where the people who use and abuse and leave in ruin that infrastructure will take it upon themselves to fix that infrastructure with all the jobs they create and all the taxes they don’t pay… because subsidies are returned at 21,000% the rate of lobbying costs… because of who you send to Congress.

            If you feel underrepresented and you are even a little cynical, you can only come to the conclusion that it’s us against them, and those who bring the pork home are the evil ones? Why isn’t it that your representation sucks and/or has sold you down the road for his or her payday, and s/he doesn’t even have the decency to throw you a bone?

            You’ve said it here. Do it for the vets, not just the ones you think are being damned. Every single one of them gets damned, not just the ones you want to talk about. It has nothing to do with demographics on the micro level and everything to do with the macro.

            I hope they do what’s needed now that they can take the credit. It will be cronied, inefficient and scandal-ridden like most other GOP ventures… and any ventures involving Dems who are also flat-earthers. You think the VA paperwork stuff is new? Problems that never get addressed are supposed to clear themselves up because of what? The market the VA is expressly forbidden by law from participating in?

          • Other than the words you keep trying to put in my mouth, I don’t think we even mostly disagree on this issue. Our disagreement seems to stem from my strong suspicion that if the Vietnam veterans were 85% African-American instead of 85% Caucasian, Obama would care more. Neither of us can prove that either way, but the Democrats’ rhetoric and even campaign strategies indicate they don’t really care about white guys, except as a target for blame and demonization. Maybe if the other 15% was more vocal or visible (not blaming them) there would have been some actual care from the administration. Yes, slightly tongue in cheek here.

            I used to be a strong Democrat, but the way they have treated half my racial makeup and my gender, among other things, have played a big role in pushing me third-party and away from that part of the political spectrum.

            I want leaders who will fight for all Americans and recognize people’s struggles, paying attention to more than simple majority/minority status. It’s hard to find, and this election didn’t give us great choices, that’s for sure.

          • … my strong suspicion that if the Vietnam veterans were 85% African-American instead of 85% Caucasian, Obama would care more.

            He wouldn’t.

            Neither of us can prove that either way,

            Correct, you can’t prove a negative. But we can take the lawmakers at their words and gauge their actions accordingly, which is what I’m doing. Changing the personal demographics only makes it more likely that Obama would what? Not get anything done like he’s allowed to do now?

            … the Democrats’ rhetoric and even campaign strategies indicate they don’t really care about white guys, except as a target for blame and demonization.

            This is the point I’m trying to make. I won’t defend HRC’s tactics because I lived them too. But where she failed is precisely where you’re failing. Obama understood inclusion and equality, even if he did move right of center before he even became prez. Pandering to specific demographics within a group is just that, pandering.

            Remember when I told you that the Bernie Bro phenomenon wasn’t just disenfranchised white males? Well neither are your disenfranchised white males just disenfranchised white males. But you don’t seem to be able to move beyond that even if you know deep down it’s true. I don’t blame you for that. I blame the hucksters who played you against someone just like you but looks different than you or lives in a different region. Minorities have left their liberal intuitions behind and traded equality for the more conservative ideal known as identity. And why not? Those who don’t have power/money/whatever learn how to accumulate and keep these objectives from someone.

            So let’s take it to the extreme and just make it about race. Let’s go after the separatists. They’re supposedly highly conservative. What if we break them down along racial lines? Are the Nation of Islam liberal because they’re black? Or are they conservative because they’re separatists? That’s the difference in our points of view in a nutshell. If you look at it from an equality standpoint, you can’t think anything but the latter. If you’re stuck listening to hucksters telling you what to think of people based on their identities, then you believe the former… for no good reason whatsoever.

          • You’re putting words into my mouth again and erroneously assuming opinions. Not worth the arguebeavs.

            I do respect your opinion overall, though, nutty a poster as you often are :P

          • I’m saying that bringing up race at all is an insult to anyone who knows policy and wants equality. I feel like we’re arguing this:
            http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/frame_game/2012/09/romney_s_47_percent_vs_obama_s_cling_to_guns_or_religion_which_gaffe_is_worse_.html

            Guess who pounced on only the guns/religion/anti-immigration part in order to play identity politics with her would-be supporters? She sowed those seeds and just had her only harvest. But the GOP also sows these seeds, and they won with the the biggest Johnny Haterseed of them all.

            The truth is that the same jobs are never coming back to those sectors. But there are new sectors to add if the people would hire someone who would give them the power of knowledge, not pretend to empower them with fear.

      • The only way Obama was going to get the GOP to do anything for vets is if he came out one day and said they all deserve nothing and no healthcare… and they certainly shouldn’t be compensated for all our government’s experimental warfare methods that at varying times irradiated or poisoned or just straight up killed our own.

        And even then I think the GOP would pause for a long time before they did anything for vets. But it would be opposite of what Obama wants… so they would do it.

        Gotta work within the system.

  17. Sounds like duck Pharaoh Brown is in trouble now, for violence over the past couple of years.

    We keep losing guys to injury and oregon keeps losing guys to legal trouble. Civil war is truly going to be a war of attrition.

    • Yeah, war of attrition. That’d be the fault of Bush or the GOP, just ask Jack.

      Sorry I posted the excerpt from the Mercury News above. I should have just said something like, “If you’ve eaten fish in SE Asia which wasn’t fully cooked, EVEN IN THE LAST 50 YEARS, you could STILL be at risk for liver flukes.”

        • Oh wait… you’re asking me.

          I don’t have any such sources to link. Frankly, the connection is beyond ludicrous. And the suggestion that I don’t back up what I say with at least half credible sources (by, admittedly, the big bad “media”… who writes wurds and stuff) when on the fly is just more dissonance on your part.

          Wake up dudes. If you don’t realize that everything you’re complaining about is about to get 100 times worse because the keys to the country were just given to a grifter, you’re in a deep deep bunker… probably with enough buckets of cheese balls to outlast any fallout.

          • Did they also cite the community organizer’s pending fraud and racketeering charges… and six bankruptcies that bilked thousands of trades and vendors… and lenders as well… which led to him being beholden to foreign interests for capital?

            Is that what you heard?

            Or did you hear about Honolulu magically turning into Nairobi… which was apparently a part of the Republic of Kenya three years before the Republic of Kenya existed… while some orange dildo was holding up some piece of paper and screaming all these “facts” as they were proven on this very piece of paper he was holding up?

            Is that what you’re hearing right now?

            Cognitive dissonance.

            You wonder why people make fun of you… if you feel like one of the idiotic wusses who this all applies to? It’s because you can’t even get past this to see that the real problems you do have are rooted in the policy you don’t read because you’re stuck on this baloney.

            … not that propaganda and programming is or ever will be a thing… ever.

            And you’ve managed to paint yourselves into a corner. If he’s impeached or can’t serve his whole term, the ass isn’t the only place the GOP will be fucking us.

          • Trump: What did you mean when you said “His promises are as worthless as a degree from Trump University”

            Romney: Did I say “worthless”? I meant “priceless”, really I did. Can I have a job now?

  18. Word is “they” want people bickering/fighting with each other, that way “they” can get away with “it”. And we’re stupid enough to go along with it (this is another it).

    Based on what’s going on my conclusion is the American people are doomed and we deserve what we’ll be getting.

    BWDIK

      • Cali JC is pretty good football. Lots of true D1 prospects who couldn’t make the grades in high school and most likely won’t make the grades in JC either. Lutton is in a unique position because he already made it to D1 then backtracked.

      • If Mannion is 1, Mariota 10, probably 5.5. I think he can move a little, particularly if he came from an offense where previously he had to keep the ball and run some times.

        Again, I like either the Luck or Dalton attribute of throwing first, running to move the chains, keep the D honest and off balance. I hope this kid could move at least as well as Dalton did at TCU.

    • His Comp% is up to 64% in conference which I would consider what you need to minimally have in the Pac-12. But is TD – Int stat is really good which leads me to believe that he either (1) throws the ball away a lot or (2) puts it where only his guy might be able to catch it. That’s my orange colored glasses view of it anyway.

          • Oh yes ….can’t wait for the four quarterback system of Garretson, Blount, Collins, and Luton. What Garretson can’t do with his legs, Blount will do with his mind, Collins his jumps, and Luton his arm.

          • You’re missing one more for spring ball and another for the fall.

            I’m just in wait and see mode at this point. Our team has shown that they can be a good team this year, but a lack of talent just leads to us getting beaten up. Come back next year healthy, smarter and with more depth, and even QB issues shouldn’t be able to hold the whole team back.

      • I think you’re right. I’m being proven wrong by Mariota in the NFL right now. I thought he would get a couple years of decent play before defensive coordinators could write a book on him. Then he would fall apart like almost all the other QBs from those systems. I thought Newton would break the mold because of his size. I don’t know if that’s going to happen anymore. But Mariota seems to be using his head more and his feet less. And he was always good enough to not turn the ball over too much. If he can settle into 25-30 TDs and about half that in INTs while operating an offense that can run the ball, he could be on the level of similar QBs. I would say he has the makings of a Donovan McNabb type career. I wouldn’t call playoff wins, but Mariota has always had that “it” factor. So I wouldn’t put it past him to do just a little more under pressure and turn that kind of career into an Eli Manning type career with the organization strengths he benefits from.

        Back on the college level, having a QB comfortable enough with this gadget system is most important. We’ve discovered that it can’t be run by a QB who only runs or only throws… or who can do neither at times. Just put the ball in the spot where the D isn’t, and let your playmakers go get it. If you can get that down, you can look like you’re toying with a D… especially a Banker D.

        • I guess I should ask:

          If Newton peters out and his career ends prematurely (or on schedule according to how he’s played the game up to now), would he be considered a successful NFL QB?

          • I think being named league MVP and leading your team to the Superbowl would automatically put one in the successful category. Longevity can also put you there, but maybe on a separate axis.

          • That’s what I was wondering. It’s possible he has one amazing year and flashes out. I was wondering if he’d be tossed to the scrap heap like a so-so QB who has won a SB.

  19. Sprague on the radio saying we are an McM injury away from burning Morans redshirt. Apparently Blount has an injured hand, and with Collins illness, we’re out of options. Would suck to have to waste that redshirt with only 2 games left.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here